Fate: Max, Bigger and Buckley

I found what Max said about Bigger during the trial to be very moving. He pointed out many of the things wrong in their society. For example, why this crime had received so much negative press and angry mobs. Max points out that the mobs and Bigger are strangers, blinded by hate. People had already assumed Bigger was guilty of murder and rape before the trial, this was mostly stemmed is racism. Max explains the problems of segregation and how blacks are oppressed, he tells the story from Bigger’s point of view, saying he didn’t kill, but theoretically lived for the first time of his life. I appreciate Max; I think he and Jan were the only ones who were honestly trying to help Bigger. They were the only ones who saw the truth. In Buckley’s testimony, he brings up the rape of Mary frequently and believes Bigger had planned the entire crime before it was committed. Both of these we know to be false. The problem is, those in the book don’t know this except for Max and Jan. The underlying racism and hints that Bigger is emotionless and sadistic were shown in the press coverage, the statements given by Buckley prior to the trial and the testimony of Buckley.  When comparing the two testimonies, Max vs. Buckley, I see a major difference between the two. Max’s testimony was rooted in hope, hope for a better society, hope for acceptance and a hope for the public to see the flaws, why this segregation and racism is helping no one and needs to stop. Buckley’s testimony does the opposite of this; his is rooted in hate and hopes to inflict this same hate and fear of Bigger into others. Buckley's prosecution is what Max was trying to dissuade the public from. Sadly, the public sees Buckley’s side of the story, as opposed to Max’s. This results in Bigger being sentenced to death.